Local beat data holds two direct
redside shiner records at Johnston Creek and no direct trout observations, which is a thin signal against Windermere's wider fish assemblage of trout, char,
kokanee and whitefish alongside sculpins, suckers, bass, dace, pikeminnow, peamouth and redside shiner. That puts Johnston in the same category as nearby
Holland Creek: forage and scout water first, not a destination fishery, until access, flow and fish presence are confirmed on the ground.
If a legal, cool-water reach turns up, keep patterns small and forage-matching for the shiner-dominated food base: tiny soft hackles,
Hare's Ear,
Pheasant Tail,
Elk Hair Caddis, a small
Adams and micro fry patterns fished away from any spawning fish. The lake-edge food base here likely runs
redside shiner, other
baitfish and fry, chironomids, small
mayflies,
caddisflies, midges,
damselflies and summer
terrestrials.