Wilbur Lake's fishing is built entirely on its hatchery plant:
rainbow trout are the only species on record here, and the fishery is a straightforward put-grow program rather than a lake with a wild population to protect. General regional guidance for small East Kootenay stillwaters applies at this size and depth: a
chironomid pupa fished slow under an indicator over the shoal, or a
leech pattern such as a
Woolly Bugger worked on a slow retrieve, covers most of what a shallow, mostly-shoal lake like this has to offer.
Scuds and
zooplankton are the typical summer diet staples on comparable East Kootenay stillwaters once the early hatches taper off.
A steady, small put-grow program
Wilbur's stocking record runs back to 1960 under a mix of older strains (Badger, Tunkwa, Premier, Blackwater and others), but the program has settled into a consistent rhythm since the late 2010s: 1,000 Pennask-strain rainbow trout yearlings from the Beaver hatchery, released every spring, most recently on 2026-05-11. There is no kokanee or second species in the record, just a small, reliable annual top-up.