The stocking record is the closest thing this lake has to a fishing report, and it tells two different stories. From 1969 to 1999 the province ran Dorothy as a
brook trout nursery, dropping roughly 2,000 wild-origin Aylmer-strain fingerlings most years. In 2000 that program stopped and switched to catchable-size
rainbow trout; since 2009 it has settled into a steady annual plant of 500 Fraser Valley-strain rainbow, stocked as spring catchables averaging around 225 g. Whether any brook trout persist from the earlier program is unconfirmed; treat the current fishery as a rainbow-trout put-and-take pond.
Fished as a small stillwater, the same approach that works on comparably sized East Kootenay ponds applies here: a
chironomid pupa under an indicator worked slow near bottom, or a small
leech pattern like a
Woolly Bugger or
Balanced Leech fished on a slow retrieve, covers most of the productive water. An
Adams or other general attractor dry is worth a look during any surface activity, though no water-specific hatch record exists for Dorothy Lake to confirm timing.