South Caribou Lake is a working
put-grow fishery, and one with an unusually long paper trail: 60 recorded releases stretching back to 1923. The modern program is
rainbow trout only, Blackwater-strain yearlings delivered most springs since 2013, most recently 1,000 fish released in June 2026.
Brook trout also went into the lake in the 1930s and 40s (the last plant was 1946), but nothing has been stocked since; any that remain would be a holdover from that era, not part of the current fishery.
Fish it with standard
small-lake stillwater tactics until a local report says otherwise: a
chironomid under an indicator worked over the shoals in spring, and leech or attractor patterns like a
Woolly Bugger fished along the drop-offs, deeper here than at North Caribou, as the water warms through summer. Switch to dry-fly and emerger patterns if you find fish rising in the evening.